Posts

Trust with Accountability, Explainability, and Quality

Image
My garden is maturing nicely. Below you see the current picture of my garden. The intent is to enable a dialogue between one human and another human, a human and a machine, a machine and a human, or one machine and another machine. Or said more succinctly, a dialogue between two agents (human or machine). A new type of collaborative  work system with human and machine teaming maximizing the potential of artificial intelligence . A "conversation" and a "dialogue" are both forms of communication; but they have very distinct differences. Conversations tend to be more informal, spontaneous, unstructured. A dialogue is a particular kind of conversation which tends to be more formal, purposeful, intentional and focused, and structured. Conversation is exchanging words. Dialogue is jointly exploring meaning. You can have a conversation without dialogue. For example, two people can exchange facts and opinions without ever trying to understand one another. But every genui...

Parallels Between CAD/CAM and BIM with XBRL

Image
I have an observation: People are overhyping the role of AI in humanity's future. The way that I see it is that what is actually happening is a revolution in information and AI is one component of that revolution; not the revolution itself. AI operating on raw text is impressive. AI operating on a model of the domain is transformative. The deepest revolution is not intelligence. It is the conversion of human knowledge into stable computable structures. ( Knowledge | Stable | Computable | Structures ) As I pointed out in another blog post ; there are parallels between CAD/CAM and BIM which related to artifacts related to design, engineering, architecture, and the construction of physical things and XBRL which relates to artifacts related to accounting, reporting, auditing, analysis of financial information. I think the parallel is deeper than "both are machine interpretable structured information formats."  What I see is that they are both instances of the same fundamen...

PBCs using XBRL

Image
PBCs ("Prepared by Client" or "Provided by Client" schedules) are notoriously difficult to manage. Whether in a financial statement audit, a SOC 2 engagement, or another assurance engagement, the collection, review, tracking, correction, and rework associated with PBCs consumes enormous amounts of time and effort. So why not use XBRL for PBCs? Hear me out. A typical public company audit may involve 100 to 300 PBC requests. A middle-market financial statement audit may require 80 to 150 PBCs. A SOC 2 audit request list often contains 80 to 160 items. Despite ongoing advances in technology, these requests are still commonly managed using electronic spreadsheets, document repositories, emails, and manual workflows. Artificial intelligence can certainly help analyze these artifacts, but it is worth asking whether we are solving the right problem. In previous posts, I compared the status quo, augmented symbolic approaches, and model-driven approaches . I have argued tha...

True Cost of Quality

Image
As is explained in this short video, What is the 1-10-100 Rule? , it costs less to fix a process than to deal with defects or the consequences of defects on customers. It costs a factor of $1 to fix a process .  It costs a factor of $10 to deal the impact of a defect caused by a bad process .  It costs a factor of $100 to deal with the consequences of a failure on a customer caused by a defect .  Prevention is less expensive than correction. Correction (inspection, testing, rework) is less expensive than failure. Failure is the most expensive; defects that escape your notice and end up in the hands of a customer. Lean, Six Sigma, TQM, Agile Lean , Six Sigma , Lean Six Sigma , Total Quality Management (TQM), and Agile  are sets of philosophies, principles, techniques, practices, and methods to maximize efficiency and quality. World-class manufacturers often strive to be Lean, Six Sigma capable, quality-driven (TQM), and Agile all at the same time. While these world-c...

Conservation Law

Image
A conservation law states that a particular quantity remains unchanged as a system evolves. It may be transferred or transformed within the system, but it is neither created nor destroyed. An invariant is a quantity, relationship, or property that remains unchanged under the allowed transformations of a system. A conservation law describes what is conserved. An invariant is the mathematical expression of that conservation. A conservation law is a principle; an invariant is the quantity or equation that stays unchanged because of that principle. Here are three examples of systems that adhere to the notion of conservation law: Physics : conservation of energy; energy is not created or destroyed; the energy just moves; the invariant is total energy. Chemistry : conservation of mass (atoms); the inventory of atoms does not change; the count of each atomic species is the invariant. Accounting : conservation of resources and obligations; the resources must always equal the claims on tho...

The Tick Mark Becoming a Test

Image
Accountants have always had a model and forgot it . Every accountant already believes fiercely in invariants; but they just don't use that specific word. But they understand the idea. The whole pedagogy is this: you already know what should be true. Now say it out loud, in a form the machine can check. That is the tick mark becoming a test. That single move unlocks everything else. Once an assertion is a test, it can be run, rerun, and run at scale; which means it becomes subject to Lean, Six Sigma, TQM, Agile, the whole family of disciplines that turn one-off craft into reliable process. The point is not methodology fashion. The point is that tests are what make an accounting workflow industrial: repeatable, reviewable, improvable. The simplicity trap . A spreadsheet feels simpler than a model, and that is true. But that simplicity comes from the limited expressive power of the spreadsheet. A model can represent far more than a spreadsheet ever could . It carries information, str...